Prasnamarga and Historicity

This thread on Twitter was written when a Commie in Saffron protagonist, a newbie lawyer who with half baked knowledge of deracinated laws began seeking history of certain practices in Temples. His logic, if it is not dated to a time he cannot remember, it is not acceptable. Height was when he mocked much revered, time tested traditions of the state that feeds him (both bread for living and political affiliation that is supposed to uphold those traditions)

It began when he bluffed about an outcome of a Devaprashnam, and his advise on Sabarimala which his mentor took seriously and shot his mouth off, which was beginning of his steep downward slide. Despite changing the stance subsequently damage was done to him and there was no reversal.

(You can read about the power and accuracy of Devaprashnam, the Prasnamarga of the Jyotisha Shastra in my piece #KeralaFloods: Devaprashnam – Conversation with the Divine in Sabarimala & Warnings Ignored)

I cannot endorse nor refute the Shastra since I consider myself absolute ineligible to even talk about it leave alone judge it. Just reproduced the Facts as it were.

https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052097243669569536
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052098235228131328
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052099673014657024
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052128241341923328
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052218716174409729
https://twitter.com/mohandastg/status/1052146811031367681
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052216816066600961
https://twitter.com/mohandastg/status/1052238949043777537
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052100342622621697
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052243752172040193
https://twitter.com/mohandastg/status/1052244815457517568
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052246107294785536
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052246593066426368
https://twitter.com/mohandastg/status/1052253736720977920
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052255960151023616
https://twitter.com/mohandastg/status/1052259482259136513

When he tried to cosy up when someone jumped in to defend his contempt (see next tweet). Fact that all those supported him realised what he was and deleted their tweets in support
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052260057625313282
https://twitter.com/mohandastg/status/1052261639947350016
And he did not have any information yet dissed a time tested and much honored tradition!
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052262518251433984
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052263165738782721
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052245358267564032
https://twitter.com/mohandastg/status/1052250302768979969
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052258871463428096
https://twitter.com/mohandastg/status/1052260164391309318
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052260829868032000
https://twitter.com/mohandastg/status/1052263282185302017
https://twitter.com/mohandastg/status/1052270975318933506
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052274845587791872
https://twitter.com/eabhvee/status/1052275994793598978
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052290982451048449
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052292365937991680
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052291844929986562
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1052603915236139008

Not sure what was the argument of that tweep. But my clarification is here

Adding some related tweets on the subject

https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1054349194838843392
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1019216407266054144
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1019218456099606528
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1019218728490291201
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1019219264660819972
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1019221195739287552

https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1019218728490291201
https://twitter.com/surnell/status/1051200723793383424

#KeralaFloods: Devaprashnam – Conversation with the Divine in Sabarimala & Warnings Ignored

Now the the worst phase of the man made (to be specific, Communists made, click here #CommieMadeDisaster for what Twitter felt about it)  disaster in Kerala, the worst flood of the century, is over and has entered Rehabilitation phase, time to look back at possible lessons (that we will still not learn). Starting this series with a Mystical Event (based on experiences shared by many who have partaken it in the past) that took place in Sabarimala – The Ashtamangala Devaprashnam. While the focus of this piece is not to explain or defend the practice (I am a non-entity to write a commentary on much revered Prasna Marga, leave alone Deva Prashna which is altogether a different realm. It is to highlight the findings which got published in various media way back in June 2018 (that is 2 months before the disaster struck Kerala). Point is not even that, why selectively some recommendations (that got material or pecuniary benefit to some) got accepted and implemented in a jiffy but that which (with benefit of hindisight) affected much larger population were not even deemed worthy of a look-in

The Devaprashnam was primarily called for, because of the incident where an Elephant carrying the Idol from Sannidhanam to Arattu Kadavu ran amok injuing a few pilgrims and setting panic. (Manorama News Report below)

The Devaprashnam was delayed and held only in June 2018, because of passing away of Tantri Kandararu Maheshwararu.

Here is the article published in June 2018 Edition of “Sree Ayyappan” official monthly of Akhila Bharatha Ayyapa Seva Sangham on the findings of the Devaprashnam.

The one below is another clipping I recieved on Whatsapp from a friend

There was a Television report telecast (according to information given to me) on June 18th 2018, where the findings and warning about disasters in Pamba was mentioned.

Credit: TV Janam

Summary of the findings and remedies (from the Sree Ayyappan Magazine)

The changes that has been brought in the rituals is not to the liking of the Lord Ayyappa. The 5 day Ezhunallathu ritual (Procession) done after Makara Vilakku for Malikapurattamma has deviated a lot. There is a  displeasure seen in Lord for discontinuing the practice of using Elephant for this ezhunallathu during the Makara (Jan-Feb) month. If there has been trouble with Elephant, the remedy is not to discontinue using Elephants for the rituals, but to determine the causes for the trouble. However use of Elephant in the Meena (March-April) month is not mandatory. The defects on the Thidambu (The idol carried on the Elephant during ceremonial processions) has to be rectified immediately. Lord is unhappy for discontinuing the use of accompanying Vaal (Sword) from the ceremonial proceedings. This is an essential accessory for the Ezhunallathu.

Blocking the vision of Lord Ayyappa is the Shelter built on top of 18 Holy steps. This has to be rectified immediately. Ponnambalamedu has to be protected. Lot of shortcomings in the Naivedya also is seen. Along with Aravana, even Milk payasam has to be offered on all days. The night puja before Lord retires for resting, has to essentially have Paalpayasam as naivedya along with Tambula puja. The Tila Payasam (Sesame seed Payasam) which is currently only offered on Saturdays has to be done everyday. Ensure purity of all offerings including Sandal paste. Newly built Bhasma Kulam has no natural flow. It has to be rebuilt. ತ

Sharamkutti has been moved from its original place and is rendered impure. Vandiperiyar Subramanya Swamy temple which is closely associated with Sabarimala is totally neglected, which needs to be remedied. It is also seen that some Vaishnava temple has been destroyed which needs to be recovered and restored. Change of Kochukadutta Swamy temple also is not to Lord’s liking. Nagaraja or Snake that has a lot of significance in Sabarimala has seen some killings of snakes. Similarly, there has been killing of cow, to be remedied by building a Goshala and protect them.

Sri Rama Padam in Pamba Triveni has to be protected. There is Bhadrakali in Pamba. The change that has happened in the location where Guruthi (Symbolic blood offering to represent Vitality) has been reason for lot of repercussions.

Malikappuratamma also has to be given equal importance as in Sabarimala. THERE IS A POSSIBILITY OF A CALAMITY IN PAMBA 

TV Janam reports over and above that Kandararu Maheswararu, who expired in May, died out of pain due to removal of Mohanaru  as Sabarimala thantri over a scandal. It was found the cause for the demise of the thantri was due to son Kandararu Mohanaru’s misfortunes. Rectification of the senior thantri’s cause of worry was needed.

Translation of the picture that has point to point findings.

  1. Location of the Temple doesn’t indicate any fault
  2. Likelihood of land related disputes against Sabarimala for which some Prayaschitta (Atonement measures) have to be undertaken
  3. Increase Naivedyam (offerings) to Lord Ganapathi
  4. Need to give attention to satiating Lord Ganapathi which is ignored at this time
  5. The second installation of Lord Ganapathi in front of Homa Kunda (Sacrificial Fire place) has to be moved to appropriate location, installed and regular Puja and Abhishekham to be performed
  6. Tantri (Vedic and Spiritual Head  who decides on the Primary and core rituals and practices in a Temple) and Melshanti (Chief Priest) who currently reside within the compound of the Main Temple complex have to be moved out and located outside the compound walls.
  7. All the priests including Chief Priest should be given Orientation classes every year by Tantri on the rituals, traditions and practices.
  8. Kalabam (Sandal Paste) Abhishekam is not part of the Temple tradition. Since it is being done, ensure it is done the right way.
  9. As per the signs emerging, Lord Ayyappa is not getting comfortable and adequate rest. Tantri has to find a remedy for this.
  10. The doors of the Sanctum Sanctorum doesn’t close properly, this needs to be addressed on priority and changed at the earliest
  11. Many such defects on the structures outside the temples needs to be fixed too
  12. Most problems would be solved, just by proper worship of Lord Ayyappa
  13. Priests, Security and Police have not been noble and have been faulty through their deeds and words. This has to be remedied
  14. Priests, Police & Devaswom Security should behave properly with the Pilgrims.
  15. One of the primary reasons for these problems is misbehaviour with the devotees and pilgrims. Staff who are related to pilgrim management or interaction should be given proper training
  16. We can see signs that there is concerted efforts by various organization to defame Ayyappa Temple. Remedial (Parihaara) and Atonement (Prayaschitta) actions would help us to hear Good news in this regard.
  17. Lord is being used as a means of conducting business. This has to be stopped.
  18. Do not indicate in any forms sponsors inside the temple premises.
  19. THE DAIVAJNAS (ASTROLOGERS ASKING QUESTIONS) SEE IMPENDING CALAMITY IN PAMBA
  20. Proper puja and Naivedya (Divine Offering) to be performed in Ganapathi temple in Pamba
  21. Mahamrutjunajaya Homam to be performed every month in Sabarimala. This has to be done for one year.
  22. The rivalry between Alangad and Ambalapuzha petta thullal teams is not being liked by Lord Ayyappa. This is easy to be remedied. (For more reading about the ritualistic significance of these two teams, click HERE)
  23. Bhasmakulam (The temple pond in Sannidhanam) has to be rebuilt.
  24. Lord Ayyappa wants a part of the revenue to be earmarked for the needy.
  25. The current Devaswom board has the will to issue orders to the Management committee.

Additional Reading : 

  1. http://www.newindianexpress.com/states/kerala/2018/jun/17/devaprasnam-for-reinstatement-of-kandararu-mohanaru-as-thantri-1829247.html
  2. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/thiruvananthapuram/decks-cleared-for-the-return-of-kandararu-mohanaru/articleshow/64628998.cms