Pausing Rights, Permitting the Ritual – Thirupurankundram Saga

September 14th 2025
Amazing Portal
PC: ETV

On 20 November 2026, a Supreme Court bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul Pancholi permitted the ceremonial lighting of the Karthigai Deepam lamp at the Deepathoon on Thiruparankundram Hill as a strictly controlled, one-time arrangement for 24 November 2026. While granting this temporary relief ahead of the festival, the apex court stayed paragraphs 1 to 140 of the Madras High Court judgment and scheduled final arguments for the second week of January 2027.

Customary Practice and the Question of Precedent

Historical records and judicial observations indicate no unbroken modern custom of lighting the Karthigai Deepam lamp at the Deepathoon. For decades, the traditional festival lamp at Thiruparankundram has been lit at the customary mandapam near the Uchipillaiyar Temple rather than at the disputed stone pillar situated roughly fifty metres from the Hazrat Sultan Sikandar Badusha Auliya Dargah. Disputes over shifting the ritual higher up the hill surfaced during mid-1990s litigation, and following December 2025 High Court orders and subsequent administrative restrictions, routine worship remained anchored at the traditional temple spot.

Prompted AI Image

Even though the Supreme Court labelled its 20 November 2026 directive a narrowly confined relief incapable of legal consequence, practical reality operates differently. Once authorised Devasthanam personnel light the lamp at the Deepathoon under judicial supervision, the event becomes an undeniable historical fact. In future hearings, petitioners will inevitably point to the peaceful completion of the 24 November 2026 ceremony as proof that the ritual can proceed without disrupting public order or infringing upon the dargah.

High Court Mandate Versus Supreme Court Restraint

The Supreme Court interim order marks a sharp departure from the approach taken earlier by the Madras High Court. In December 2025 and January 2026, both a Single Judge and a Division Bench of the High Court treated the lighting of the lamp at the Deepathoon as an enforceable right and duty of the temple administration. The High Court rejected the Tamil Nadu government argument that the pillar was a colonial British survey marker, affirmed that the structure stood on temple land, and ordered execution under central police cover while initiating contempt proceedings against resisting officials.

By contrast, the Supreme Court paused every substantive legal conclusion reached below. Staying the first 140 paragraphs of the High Court ruling stripped away judicial findings on land title, archaeological identity, and religious custom. Instead of sidelining local authorities, the apex court placed the District Collector in charge as nodal officer to select a small authorised team, bar the general public and slogans, prohibit structural alterations, ensure immediate departure after the ritual, and submit a compliance report within three days.

A Century of Litigation Over the Hill

The controversy over the Deepathoon is the latest chapter in a legal battle stretching back more than a hundred years. In 1920, civil litigation erupted between the management of the Arulmigu Subramaniaswamy Temple and the Sikandar Badusha Dargah over ownership of Thiruparankundram Hill. A 1923 trial court decree divided the terrain, vesting the unoccupied hill and pilgrim pathways in the temple while confirming Muslim ownership over the topmost summit housing the mosque, the Nellithope area, and the flight of steps leading up. The Privy Council in London affirmed this settlement in 1931.

Subsequent decades tested the edges of that colonial demarcation. In 1996, the Madras High Court directed that the Karthigai Deepam continue at the Uchipillaiyar mandapam, permitting alternate locations only if situated at least fifteen metres away from the dargah, steps, and Nellithope area. Fresh disputes arose in 2021 over replacing a wooden flagstaff near the dargah with an iron pole, and in early 2025 when a three-judge bench banned animal sacrifice atop the hill under protected monument rules. Those tensions culminated in the November 2025 writ petitions, the January 2026 Division Bench affirmation, the Tamil Nadu government appeal in June 2026, and the Supreme Court interim order of November 2026.

Competing Claims Over Title and Heritage

At the heart of the dispute lie three conflicting interpretations of the stone pillar and its surrounding terrain. Temple authorities and devotee petitioners maintain that the Deepathoon is an ancient lamp column standing on a lower rocky outcrop owned by the temple, well outside the summit plateau belonging to the dargah. Dargah representatives counter that the entire upper plateau forms part of their settled property, barring new rituals nearby regardless of exact measurements. Meanwhile, the Tamil Nadu government and the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Department contend that the stone column is a secular British-era survey marker rather than a consecrated shrine.

Heritage governance adds another layer of complexity. Organisations such as the Hindu Dharma Parishad have urged the Supreme Court to hand over the hill complex to the Archaeological Survey of India under the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, alleging state failure to safeguard ancient rock-cut heritage. The state government has strongly resisted any ASI takeover, arguing that statutory religious endowment administration cannot be displaced once property rights stand settled.

The 1931 Decree and the Road to January 2027

When the Supreme Court reconvenes for final arguments in the second week of January 2027, the 1931 Privy Council decree will serve as the binding baseline under the doctrine of res judicata. Neither side can reopen the broad division of the hill settled a century ago. Instead, the court will map those 1923 survey boundaries onto modern topography to determine whether the Deepathoon falls inside temple land or within the dargah summit zone.

Even if the bench concludes that the pillar stands on temple property, ownership alone will not settle the constitutional question. Under Article 25 jurisprudence, the court must weigh whether lighting the lamp at the Deepathoon constitutes an essential religious practice or an established custom preserved by the 1931 settlement, or whether it represents a unilateral expansion of ritual near a sensitive shared site. Having cleared away the stayed High Court findings, the Supreme Court will examine original revenue maps, archaeological records, and historical custom afresh to decide if the flame lit on 24 November 2026 remains a solitary event or becomes an enduring tradition.

Rashtra Is Not Rajya

haratiya thought does not treat nation and state as same thing. Rashtra is a living community bound by land, culture and shared values, while Rajya is political machinery that governs and protects it. Dynasties and governments have changed many times, from Maurya and Gupta to Mughal and British rule, yet Rashtra has continued. This article explains Bharatiya definition of nation and nationhood, contrasts it with Western ideas of sovereignty and territory, and shows how Dharma links both concepts. Real examples from Chanakya, Shivaji Maharaj, Sardar Patel and the Emergency make each idea clear. Critical views are included for balanced reading.
Rashtra and Rajya in Bharatiya Thought

When we say nation in English, we usually mean country with borders, government, flag and army. This idea came to India through colonial education, and many of us now use it without thinking. Bharatiya tradition however has its own vocabulary to speak about people, land, culture and political authority. Two words are central here, Rashtra and Rajya. They are often used as if both mean same thing, but in traditional Bharatiya political philosophy they point to different realities. Understanding this difference helps us read our history better and also helps us understand many debates in India today.
Based on my learnings from various Nationalists and Indian Knowledge System Pandits, sharing how Bharatiya thought defines nation and nationhood, how this differs from Western definitions, and how Rashtra differs from Rajya. Real life examples are given with each idea so that concepts do not remain abstract.

Meaning of Rashtra and Rashtriyata

Rashtra is a Sanskrit word with Vedic origin. It refers to a living community of people who share land, culture, memory and values, and who feel that they belong together. Rashtriyata is nationhood, that is, the feeling and consciousness of being one people. It is not created by a treaty, a constitution or a ruler. It grows slowly over centuries through shared way of living.
In this view, Rashtra is geo-cultural. Land matters, but land alone does not make Rashtra. People matter, but people alone do not make Rashtra either. Land, people and culture together, joined by common values and civilisational memory, form Rashtra. Many thinkers say Rashtra is like body and soul together, where Rajya is only the outer organisation that looks after it.
A useful example is how Indians speak about their land. Bharat is called Matribhumi and Punyabhumi, motherland and holy land. A farmer in Punjab and a fisherman in Kerala may speak different languages and follow different customs, but both bow to river water, both celebrate harvest festivals and both recite stories of Bhagawan Shri Ram and Bhagawan Shri Krishna in their own tongue. This shared inner life, not a passport or a flag, is Rashtriyata in Bharatiya sense.

Vedic Roots of Nationhood

Vedic texts speak of Rashtra with great seriousness. Yajurveda has a well known prayer asking that we remain awake and alert for the sake of Rashtra. Rigveda, in Devi Sukta, speaks of Devi as Rashtri, the one who gathers and holds together all wealth. Atharvaveda has Bhumi Sukta, a long hymn which says Earth is mother and I am her child. This hymn does not see land as property to be owned. It sees land as mother to be served. Here, love for land and responsibility towards fellow citizens come together.
Vishnu Purana gives a clear geographical and cultural description. It says that land lying north of ocean and south of Himalayas is called Bharatavarsha and its people are Bharatiya. This verse was composed long before modern maps or modern states. Pilgrim routes, Sanskrit learning and epics had already given people a sense that one land is home.

Cultural Geography in Daily Life

Bharatiya nationhood is visible in sacred geography. Char Dham in Badrinath, Dwarka, Puri and Rameswaram, twelve Jyotirlinga, fifty one Shakti Peetha and seven sacred cities are spread across entire subcontinent. A pilgrim from Tamil Nadu walks to Kashi, and a pilgrim from Assam travels to Rameswaram. Adi Shankaracharya, born in Kerala, established four Mathas in four corners, at Sringeri, Dwarka, Puri and Jyotirmath, and walked across Bharat debating scholars. Nobody ordered this. No king had to enforce it. Culture itself bound people together.
Kumbh Mela is another example. Crores of people from different languages, castes and regions gather at Prayagraj, Haridwar, Ujjain and Nashik without any invitation by government. Sages, farmers, traders and householders all come because of shared faith in tradition. Kashi Tamil Sangamam, organised in recent years, built on same old links between Kashi and Tamil lands that were maintained for centuries.

Western Definitions of Nation

Western idea of nation developed in specific historical conditions. After Treaty of Westphalia in 1648, Europe moved towards sovereign territorial states. Later, French Revolution tied nation to citizenship and popular sovereignty. German thinkers like Herder stressed language and folk spirit, while Italian leader Mazzini linked nation to self-rule. Ernest Renan in 1882 described nation as a daily plebiscite, meaning a group that wills to live together. Max Weber defined state as institution holding monopoly on legitimate use of force over a territory. Benedict Anderson later described nations as imagined communities, produced through print, newspapers and common language.
In most of these definitions, nation and state are closely linked. Nation seeks a state, and state tries to build one nation. Territory, sovereignty, law and common citizenship become central. Western history also shows that this model was often built through standardising language, suppressing local identities and fighting wars with neighbours. Two World Wars grew out of rival nationalisms. Colonial expansion by European nation-states in Asia and Africa was also driven by this competitive model.

Contrast Between Bharatiya and Western Views

First difference is origin. Western nation is largely modern, tied to rise of state in Europe from sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. Bharatiya Rashtra is traced to Vedic period and is seen as civilisational, existing long before any modern state.
Second difference is relation with political power. In West, nation usually depends on state for protection and expression. In Bharatiya view, Rashtra continues even when Rajya changes or collapses. Maurya, Gupta, Chola, Vijayanagara, Maratha and Mughal rule came and went, and then British rule came and went, yet Bharat as cultural entity continued.
Third difference is basis of unity. Western models often seek unity through sameness of language, ethnicity or citizenship. Bharatiya thinking accepts diversity as natural and looks for unity within it. Same Rashtra holds Tamil, Bengali, Marathi and Dogri speakers, worshippers of Shiva, Vishnu, Devi, Buddha and Mahavira, and also those who follow Islam, Christianity and other paths. Idea of unity here is that diversity is expression of one underlying whole, not a problem to be removed.
Fourth difference is attitude to others. Many Bharatiya writers argue that Rashtra was never meant to expand over others or to impose itself. Shri Krishna Deva Raya or Chola kings did conquer and build influence, but Bharatiya tradition of Dharma Vijay, victory with righteousness, as seen in Emperor Ashoka’s turn after Kalinga, shows an ideal where power is limited by ethics. Ancient Bharat also gave refuge to Parsis and Jewish communities, and this is often cited as living proof of this attitude.

Rajya in Bharatiya Philosophy

Rajya refers to political authority and its machinery. It means state, kingdom, government, administration, army, treasury and courts. Its purpose was to protect people and enable them to follow Dharma. Raja was not owner of land or people. He was a trustee whose duty was Rajadharma, which means to protect, to be just and to promote welfare of subjects.
Kautilya in Arthashastra describes Rajya through Saptanga theory, seven limbs of state. These are Swami or ruler, Amatya or ministers, Janapada or territory and people, Durga or fort, Kosha or treasury, Danda or force and Mitra or allies. This is a practical and almost scientific description of state. Mahabharata, especially Shanti Parva, gives equal stress to ethics of rulership. Bhishma instructs Yudhishthira that a king who does not protect his people has failed in duty. Ramayana presents Ram Rajya as ideal, where ruler places public good above personal happiness. Maharshi Valmiki shows Bhagawan Shri Ram giving up his beloved Devi Sita for sake of Rajadharma, which is an example of how heavy this duty was considered.
One striking idea is that Rajya itself is under Dharma. In Bharatiya thought, King is not source of law. Dharma is higher than king. Even Raja can be corrected by rishis, by assemblies like Sabha and Samiti and by public opinion. Story of Vena in Puranas, a king removed by sages for turning unjust, is often cited here.

Difference Between Rashtra and Rajya

Rashtra is permanent while Rajya is changing. Rashtra is cultural and moral while Rajya is political and administrative. Rashtra is about who we are, and Rajya is about how we are governed. Rashtra is like soul and Rajya is like body, which is a comparison often repeated by scholars and writers. Rashtra is not created by anybody, while Rajya is created, improved, replaced or destroyed.
Another difference is purpose. Rashtra exists to express and preserve civilisational values and to give each person a sense of belonging. Rajya exists to provide security, justice, order and welfare so that these values can be lived. If Rajya works well, Rashtra flourishes. If Rajya turns unjust, it harms Rashtra, and tradition then expects people and wise leaders to correct it.
It is also important to note that ancient texts do not always keep these two completely apart. In Ramayana, Queen Kaushalya says that due to exile of Ram, both Rajya and Rashtra would suffer. In Mahabharata, Yudhishthira speaks of regaining both after exile. Scholars like Ranga Hari point out that in early texts these two concepts overlapped in usage, and clear separation developed more in later reflection. So distinction is best understood as difference of function and depth, not strict division in every text.

Role of Dharma as Link

Dharma Chakra links Rashtra and Rajya

Dharma connects Rashtra and Rajya. Dharma here does not mean religion in narrow sense of worship or belief. It means moral order, duty and right conduct that holds society together. Rajya must follow Dharma, and Rashtra expresses Dharma. When ruler acts according to Dharma, Rajya and Rashtra move together. When ruler acts against Dharma, tension appears.

Real Life Examples of Rashtra and Rajya

Chandragupta Maurya and Chanakya

Chanakya did not create Rashtra. He understood that Bharat already existed as cultural and geographical reality, but it was divided under many small Rajyas and exposed to foreign invasion after Alexander’s campaign. His project was to build a strong Rajya that could protect and unify this Rashtra. This shows both concepts clearly. Rashtra was already there, and Rajya was the instrument.

Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj

Shivaji Maharaj established Hindavi Swarajya in seventeenth century at a time when Mughal and Sultanate Rajyas dominated most of Bharat. He built administration, navy, forts and revenue system, which is Rajya building. Yet his coronation at Raigad in 1674 was conducted with Vedic rites by Pandit Gaga Bhatt, and he spoke of protecting dharma, cows, Brahmins and temples along with all subjects. Here a new Rajya was made to serve an older Rashtra.

Survival under British Rule

British Rajya controlled Bharat for nearly two centuries. It changed laws, education and economy. Still, Rashtra did not disappear. Festivals like Ganeshotsav, made public by Lokmanya Tilak, Vande Mataram sung from Bankim Chandra Chatterjee’s Anandamath, and Swami Vivekananda’s speeches kept Rashtriya consciousness alive. Freedom movement was in essence an effort to bring Rajya in line with Rashtra.

Integration of Princely States

In 1947, there were around 565 princely states. Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, with V. P. Menon, persuaded most to join Union of India, and used firm measures in cases like Hyderabad and Junagadh. His work was about building one Rajya for people who already felt as one Rashtra. Same Somnath temple he asked to be rebuilt after independence became a symbol of Rashtra’s resilience.

Partition of 1947

Partition shows that Rajya boundaries can change dramatically. Lines were drawn at Punjab and Bengal and new states came up. Yet shared culture, food, music, language and family ties across borders continued. Many people on both sides still feel this inner link. This example is used by thinkers to show that political borders do not fully define nationhood.

Constitution and Its Spirit

Constitution of India adopted in 1950 is a foundational document of Rajya. It sets up Parliament, courts and executive, and guarantees rights. Many Bharatiya thinkers see in it values that match Rashtra, such as plurality and justice, while some argue that its structure follows Western models too closely. Placing of images from Ramayana, Mahabharata and Vedic period in original Constitution pages, drawn by artists of Shantiniketan under Nandalal Bose, is often cited as sign of Rashtra’s presence in Rajya’s founding document.

Emergency of 1975 to 1977

During Emergency, Rajya used its power to suspend civil rights and press freedom. Public resistance and eventual electoral defeat in 1977 are cited as example of Rashtra correcting Rajya, an idea close to older view that Rajya is answerable to Dharma and people.

Sengol in New Parliament

In 2023, Sengol, a sceptre linked with Chola tradition of righteous rule, was installed in new Parliament building. Supporters see this as modern Rajya acknowledging old Rashtra values of Rajadharma. Critics ask whether such symbolism is needed in a secular republic. This debate itself shows how question of relation between Rashtra and Rajya remains alive.

Hindu Rashtra and Secular Rajya

Leaders like Atal Bihari Vajpayee used this framework to say that Bharat is a Hindu Rashtra in cultural sense, but state should be non-partisan and treat all citizens equally. V. D. Savarkar and others developed similar thinking. Supporters say this reconciles cultural identity with equal citizenship. Critics argue that using the word Hindu for nationhood can make citizens of other faiths feel excluded, and that Constitution already defines nationhood through equal citizenship. Readers should study both sides.

Other Views and Debates

Not all scholars accept this framework as presented. Some historians say that pre-modern Bharat had strong cultural unity but no single political idea of nation as understood today, and that reading modern nationhood into ancient texts is anachronistic. Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, in his final speech in Constituent Assembly, warned that Bharat was still a nation in making and caste divisions were serious obstacle. Rabindranath Tagore was critical of narrow nationalism and stressed universal humanism. Jawaharlal Nehru in Discovery of India described Bharat as a palimpsest of many layers, where unity came from shared experience over time. Constitutional thinkers stress that citizenship, and not culture or religion, is legal basis of nationhood in Bharat today.
Many writers who support Bharatiya framework in turn reply that these views also accept deep civilisational unity, and that what is needed is better language to describe it than imported words. Sources used for this article include writings from RSS affiliated authors, academic course material from University of Delhi, and articles on Rajya and Rashtra distinction, so reader should also look at other perspectives for balanced understanding.

Conclusion

Bharatiya definition of nation rests on Rashtra, a living cultural and spiritual community bound to land and shared values, expressed through Rashtriyata or nationhood. Western definitions emphasise sovereignty, territory, language and citizenship, and tie nation closely to state. In Bharatiya tradition, Rajya is institution that governs and protects, answerable to Dharma, while Rashtra is deeper identity that outlives every dynasty and government. From Chanakya to Shivaji Maharaj, from Sardar Patel to modern Parliament, examples show how Rajya has repeatedly been built, changed and judged by its service to Rashtra. Whether one fully agrees with this framework or not, it gives a rich way to understand Bharat on its own terms and not only through borrowed categories.

Literacy to Capability Gap

Received feedback on my previous article (click to read it – it opens in another window) seeking me to explain what my sign-off statement meant. I have attempted to explain the progression that highlights the critical gap between acquiring information and applying it effectively in real life.

Literacy and Education

Literacy is merely the foundational tool of reading and writing. Education expands upon this through structured learning and formal certification. Yet possessing degrees does not guarantee true understanding, as traditional schooling often rewards rote memorisation over independent thought.

Knowledge and Wisdom

Knowledge is the accumulation of facts, theories, and technical data gathered through study or experience. Wisdom sits much higher, representing the sound judgement to discern right from wrong and apply those facts thoughtfully. Many individuals hold vast knowledge yet lack the practical sense to navigate complex human dilemmas.

Gap to Capability

Capability is the ultimate test of execution, adaptability, and resilience under pressure. Knowing how a system functions or holding the wisdom to advise others does not automatically translate into the competence to deliver results when stakes are high. True capability demands grit, emotional intelligence, and decisive action in unpredictable environments.