#PCWedsNDTV – Unending Saga of Ex-NDTV Journo’s Journey of (Un)truths

There was this guy an Ex-NDTV Journalist (If I can call him one) who was trying to bull-doze his way into lying, then abusing and then crying victim all behind a “Impregnable” (atleast that is why he thought) fort of lies he erected around his original lies.

This piece is not judging any players involved but placing plain facts before readers – Request to see this just as that. But what I definitely intend to do is to call the bluff of this journalist, based on strongest evidence.

Prelude:

The entire debate was re-triggered in recent times (Jan 5th, 2014 to be precise),  after Sri Gurumurthy ji shared Sri Ram Jethmalani letter to Finance Minister P. Chidambaram regarding NDTV money laundering.

 

GuruMurthy-RamJLetterPC-Sharing-
Click on the Picture to read Original tweet (if it still exist)

You can read copy of Sri Ram Jethmalani’s letter to Finance Minister P Chidambaram here 

We knew something was amiss when Finance Minister’s oblique (and culprit-like dismissive) response to Sri Ram Jethmalani’s letter. Sri Ram Jethmalani shred PC response to pieces.

GuruMurthy-PCReply-RamJLetterPC-Sharing-
Click on the Picture to read Original tweet (if it still exist)

You can read copy of Sri Ram Jethmalani shredding apart Finance Minister P Chidambaram’s reply here

Now that the premise is set, this Ex-NDTV Journo set on a tirade, setting Twitter ablaze with a litany of lies, threats and “failed” sarcasm. Social media was upto this game which hitherto was ruled by the Paid media. The entire debate on Twitter was hashtagged #PCWedsNDTV and slowly but surely every single bluff was being called. Needless to say, though it was a trending topic on Twitter,

PCWedsNDTV-Trending-01

Diverting from the purpose of this piece a bit – Did we see even a whimper from any Main Stream Media on this subject? Though unacceptable, perfectly understandable. OMERTA – if they speak about NDTV, it is a cinch skeletons in every Paid Media’s cupboard will tumble out.

Back to the story….It was during this #PCWedsNDTV debate that the Ex-NDTV journo tweeted an unsolicited response to  Sri S Gurumurthy (Prophetically, I had tweeted right away that this would come to haunt him soon) 

Abhisar-NDTV-Joining-01
Letter in the bottom not in Original tweet
Added to make it readable). Click pic for Original Tweet (if it still exist)

And then he set out on a raging debate justifying a couple of things about the Officer who assessed Income Tax returns of NDTV. He starts with a threat to sue (for sharing a document in public domain)

Abhisar-Threatening
Click pic for Original Tweet (if it still exist)
Abhisar-NDTV-ConversationWithUs
Click pic for Original Tweet (if it still exist)

And when he realized legally that was a dud! Launches on to some defense that was pathetic (on hindsight, it was abominable as you would realize later in this piece) – He claimed in a series of tweets thus:

Tweet 1: “bt she ws nt assessing ndtv wn I ws thr. Wrng. Srivastava ws chargesheetd by vigilance. Lies spd by him”

Tweet 2: her boss ws assessing it. Nt her. She jst signed refund tht means nthing. Alphabet “n” fell in her domain

AbhisarSharma-SumanaNotAssessing-01

AbhisarSharma-SumanaNotAssessing
Click pic for Original Tweet (if it still exist)

He tried to hold forte, but unfortunately for him it was not an anchored show on MSM. With more evidences pouring in, he cried victim and vamoosed and thought the matter would die a natural death

The finale: RTI response received cleared indicates all the above from this Ex-NDTV Journo was a blatant lie. Here is the copy of RTI response with sections highlighted.

NDTV 1.46 crores refund RTI - 1 of 2

NDTV 1.46 crores refund RTI - 2 of 2

A note on Item 10 on page 2 of the RTI response above

The refund of Rs. 14682836/- to NDTV passed by “her”  DCIT is ILLEGAL because:

As per the Supreme Court judgement in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax vs Gujarat Electricity Board of 12th November 2002 (see order: http://indiankanoon.org/doc/1244968/), no order u/s 143 (1)(a) can be passed once a notice u/s 143 (2) is issued. In this case notice u/s 143 (2) was issued by Shri Hemant K. Sarangi, Addl.CIT on 13.12.2004 and order of refund u/s 143 (1)(a) was passed by “her”, DCIT on 28.03.2005.

Interestingly NDTV’s case for AY 2004-2005 was already being handled by Shri Hemant K. Sarangi, Addl. CIT, senior of “her”, DCIT and therefore she could not have attended to the case as there cannot be more than one assessing officer in a case at the same time!

Readers can now judge on the claims of this Ex-NDTV journo

  1. Wasn’t this journo in employment of NDTV when this assessment was made
  2. Wasn’t the “She” assessing officer contrary to what he claimed
  3. Wasn’t “she” the one who raised the refund order,
  4. Wasn’t “she” the one who signed the refund order, not by virtue of letter “n” but as one who raised it???

Watch this space!!! More of such Facts Coming Up!

Puts a Commercial block buster to shame – PCWedsNDTV is a massive cover-up involving all ingredients of a popular Masala Thriller.

Enhanced by Zemanta
Advertisements

6 thoughts on “#PCWedsNDTV – Unending Saga of Ex-NDTV Journo’s Journey of (Un)truths

  1. Suresh's Papa April 4, 2014 / 2:49 pm

    Waaah!

    Atleast learn to read your own “Proof”? It clearly says she was the assessing officer who “PROCESSED” (point 1) . Get it? Processed! Even a computer does that . Now read the column below of your earth shattering proof which is number 3:
    Name and designation of of “assessing” officer who issues notice under 143(2) : Hemant Sarangi , Addnl CIT.

    See! So simple . Wish you had been a little more patient in reading your own proof. Processsed and assessed. Shumana Sen Just processed it and Hemant Sarangi assessed it.

    And since you have been pimping for Srivastava, why dont you ask him that there was a CVC enquiry in the entire case. Details of which are with the Govt. Since he is an expert in leaking confidential government files, why dont you ask him to provide you that ?
    The matter Mr Humpty Dumpty who shall soon have a great fall( and mark my words) is that CVC has investigated the matter and it is shut.

    All I am trying to tell you is that dont parade your stupidity in a public forum my child.

  2. srivastava April 4, 2014 / 3:07 pm

    Do you reaLise that Srivstava has leaked a confidential government document ( an assessing order through you? Do you know its a crime in court of law?
    The fact that Sumedh Swani did not give the assessing order to the assesee and leaked it in public only shows he is IN COLLUSION with Srivastava . NDTV has also taxed the stock options …so why did Sumedh swani penalise Abhisar? It is all a part of record . 37 lakhs out of those 43 have already been taxed and it is part of record. And isnt it a a part of government procedure to issue a show cause notice to the assessee in case the department has doubt on something? Why did Sumedh Swani not issue notice? Because he knew that proof will be presented to him and hence Srivastava and his sons like you will miss out on some slanderous fun on twitter .

    And none of the stock options have been excercised. The stocks were valued at 500 rupees then . It is just 50 rupees today. So how did you come to this conclusion my son? ( You must be so confused with suspected fathers running around)

    Thoda padh liya karo..Akal ka istemaal kar liya karo…saara waqt tumhara rasam pongal khaane me nikal jaata hai ..akal kahan se lagaoge ….vangooooo poda maireee 🙂

  3. Aslam Bhai April 28, 2014 / 3:26 pm

    the last 2 comments.. ‘suresh papa’ and ‘srivastava’ .. are for sure by abhichor sharma!

  4. double chin May 8, 2014 / 11:58 am

    aslam bhai mere aslam bhai dubai ka chasma …cheen kee chaddi aur irani chai …aslam bhai mere aslam bhai …..achche din aane waale hain ….Humpty dumpty jail jaane waale hain ….

  5. Justice June 29, 2014 / 12:31 pm

    Hello

Comments are closed.